The 7 Best Sheet Masks, According to Our Testers

Our Testing Process

With more sheet masks on the market than we can count, we identified the top 22 sheet masks we felt were best suited for our test. Our testers represented a wide range of skin types—sensitive, dry, normal, and oily–to get the most diverse and accurate results.

Prior to testing, testers were asked to arrive at the studio with a freshly cleansed and make-up-free face. Each tester selected one sheet mask that was suited to their skin type, then applied it according to packaging directions. After application, testers started a timer for how long the instructions said to keep the product on and began analyzing their experience. Whether it’s paper or hydro-gel, does the sheet mask feel smooth and comfortable or harsh and/or rough? As sheet masks are infused with a liquid/serum, does it feel lightweight or overly slimy and runny? Does it feel secure on the face or does it keep slipping off? If the sheet mask had any noticeable cuts and shapes, we also factored in how well it could fit on a range of face sizes without being too small or oversized. 

As our testers wore the sheet mask, they read over the product description to see what the sheet mask promises. Sheet masks can hydrate, calm, brighten, fight acne, reduce lines and wrinkles, or a combination of all of these features, but it will vary from product to product and skin type to skin type. After the time is up, testers removed the sheet mask, rubbed the remaining serum into the skin, and inspected their face in the mirror. Keeping the sheet mask’s claimed benefits in mind, we finalized our testing with how effective the product was overall, and if any of the results promised were supposed to be over time. (i.e. preventing wrinkles). The testers based their final feedback on three factors: comfort, application, and overall efficacy.

Once our data and the tester’s ratings were collected, we narrowed our list to a select number of winners and assigned categories based on the sheet mask’s attributes. 

What To Keep In Mind

Fit

There is nothing more frustrating than a sheet mask slipping off the skin. Although you want your sheet mask to be packed with hydrating ingredients, you also want it to fit snugly as you wear it around the house or while taking a bath. The unique fibers in the Wishful by Huda Mask allow it to cling to the face and that feature helped it snag the best overall spot. To avoid a slippery sheet mask, look for sheet masks that are slightly textured, thick in size, or include practical features, such as ear loops and additional pre-cut shapes, to help the product fit securely. 

Skin Type

While many sheet masks work for all skin types, some formulas are targeted for specific skin concerns. If you have dry skin, look for sheet masks that contain hyaluronic acid and glycerin. Those with sensitive skin might want to avoid or ease into sheet masks with retinol, but those with aging or textured skin might benefit from this ingredient. Base your purchase on what your desired results are, and what your skin is needing at the moment. 

Your Questions, Answered

Do sheet masks expire?

No matter the packaging or container they come in, all skin care products expire even if they’re left unopened. Once your sheet mask is opened, you should use it immediately to get the most out of the product’s ingredients. Two to three years is the usual date range for sheet masks and other skin care products alike. An expiration date is often stamped on the packaging to be sure. 

How often should I use a sheet mask? 

Think of your sheet mask use as you would a treatment – use it sparingly, only 2-3 times a week. Sheet masks are like an advanced version of a serum, the high dose of an ingredient can make them too potent to be used daily, especially if it contains some form of exfoliant (i.e. AHAs, BHAs). However, some sheet masks require a bit more maintenance and suggest daily use, but not every skin type will benefit or react the same from frequent application.

Are sheet masks good for your skin?

In short: yes! Sheet masks are incredibly efficient at treating the skin directly. Not only are sheet masks packed with ultra hydrating and soothing ingredients, its packaging makes it great for distributing ingredients evenly onto the skin and helping them absorb deeper. They are also beneficial for providing immediate results, which can help with reactions post-procedure, sunburns, irritations, and more. Even after the sheet is removed, the serum remains on the skin and will continue to draw benefits from the mask hours later. Plus, sheet masks are the perfect amount of pampering that you and your skin deserve.

What Is InStyle Picks? 

Did you notice the InStyle Picks seal of approval at the top of this story? That means our team of testers has reviewed every product on this list using a unique methodology to ensure it’s really worth your time, money, and attention. We may get samples for free to try but we never promise positive (or any!) coverage in exchange. Put simply: InStyle Picks are products we love, and we’ve put them to the test to be sure you will too. 

Why Shop With Us

Madison San Miguel is a contributing writer for the commerce team at InStyle, and has covered everything from fashion week to beauty product reviews. Her work has been published in Travel + Leisure, TripSavvy, Bustle, Elite Daily, V Magazine, and other lifestyle publications. In addition to her research, she went through the testing results provided by our testers to give the most accurate review.

Want more product recommendations? From best-in-class concealer to the black pants you need for work, check out all of our InStyle Picks content.